Close Menu

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    What's Hot

    Canada’s Largest LEGO Fan Exhibition Returns to Mississauga With Expanded Venue and More Than 300 Builders

    November 12, 2026

    New Report Highlights Video Games’ Growing Importance to Canadians

    November 12, 2026

    Amazon Kindle Colorsoft Signature Edition 2026 Draws Strong Interest as New Models Hit Shelves

    November 12, 2026
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Vaughan TodayVaughan Today
    • Home
    • Top News
    • World
    • Banking
    • Explore Canada
    • How to
    • Solutions
    • Contact Us
    • Editorial Policy
    Vaughan TodayVaughan Today
    Home»Top News»Boarding schools: The Canadian Historical Society tries to silence debate
    Top News

    Boarding schools: The Canadian Historical Society tries to silence debate

    Natalie SinclairBy Natalie SinclairAugust 14, 2021No Comments4 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Boarding schools: The Canadian Historical Society tries to silence debate
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Copy Link

    We are writing to you today to express our deep disappointment with the “Canada Day Declaration” of the Canadian Historical Society (CHA). She asserts that “current historical studies…make this conclusion very clear”, that is, the treatment of indigenous peoples in our country was genocide and that there is “widespread consensus among history experts” regarding the proof of “genocidal intent”.

    The CHA also attacks the profession by saying that historians have turned a blind eye to the tragedies that have marked Canadian history. There is no basis for such assertions and the CHA has no legitimacy in claiming to represent the history teachers’ view on the matter.

    The recent discovery of graves near former residential schools is tragic evidence of what the Truth and Reconciliation Commission documented in Volume 4 of its Final Report – a report we encourage all Canadians to read. We also encourage more research on burial sites across the country and support keeping a record of deceased children in these schools.

    intimidation

    However, the CHA exists to represent professional historians and, as such, has a duty to embody the ethics and values ​​of historical research. By making a declaration to support a particular interpretation of the story and insisting that only one interpretation is correct, the current leadership of the CHA has committed a fundamental departure from the standards and expectations that govern our profession.

    Through this tactic of intimidation, the CHA is acting as an activist organization and not as a professional body representing university professors. This transformation is unacceptable.

    The topic of boarding schools is a topic of discussion among researchers. Many differ in their assessments of this issue. Various interpretations are expected within a highly mobile university community on this question. This should allow for an open discussion, a diversity of viewpoints and also an assessment of the past on the basis of evidence.

    By claiming there is only one explanation, CHA leaders are putting down academics who came to a different conclusion from theirs. They offer the Canadian and Quebec audiences a so-called “consensus” that does not exist.

    Their position constitutes a departure from the basic standards of academic research. They betray the public who expects the Academy to base their arguments on facts and evidence that have been confirmed. Good intentions do not matter here, as it is essential that a professional organization of academics support diversity and openness in discussions. This is even more true when many insist on a particular explanation. In such cases, our intellectual principles are tested and must be preserved.

    This ad must be withdrawn

    We ask the CHA to withdraw its advertisement. Its real mission is to allow open discussions from all points of view while defending intellectual diversity. Her job is not to promote a single “consensus” history of Canada.

    As CHA celebrates its centenary, it must remain true to its best traditions. As a professional organization, it must advocate unreservedly objectivity, skepticism, debate and free access to resources that will help historians shed light on our history, including the darkest episodes of our past.

    Frederic Bastian, Dawson College

    Eric Bedard, Talouk University

    David J. Berkuson, University of Calgary

    John Bonet, Brock University

    Robert Bothwell, University of Toronto

    Felix Bouvier, University of Quebec at Trois-Rivieres

    Jerry Poehler, Frontier Center for Public Policy

    Patrick H. Brennan, University of Calgary

    Philip Buckner, University of London

    C.P. Champion, Editor in Chief of the Dorchester Review

    Marie-Aimée Cliche, University of Quebec in Montreal

    Rodney Clifton, University of Manitoba

    Robert Cuomo, University of Quebec in Montreal

    Terry Cobb-Wilfried, Laurier University

    Jack Cunningham, University of Toronto

    Kenneth Dewar, Mount Saint Vincent University

    Christopher Dummett, Trent University

    Patrice Dotell, Ryerson University

    Lucia Ferretti, University of Quebec at Trois-Rivieres

    Danny Fougere, University of Quebec in Montreal

    Yves Gingras, University of Quebec in Montreal

    JL Granatstein, York University

    Roger Hall, University of Western Ontario

    Rene Hardy, University of Quebec at Trois-Rivieres

    Jeffrey Hayes, University of Waterloo

    Michael Horn, York University

    P. Whitney Lackenbauer, Trent University

    Gilles Laporte, Ségépe de Vieux Montreal, and the University of Quebec in Montreal

    Margaret MacMillan, University of Oxford

    David B. Marshall, University of Calgary

    Joe Martin, University of Toronto

    Kathleen E. Macron, University of Windsor

    Ken McLaughlin, St. Jerome University

    Barbara Mesamore, Fraser Valley University

    JR Miller, University of Saskatchewan

    Toby Morantz, McGill University

    Doug Onam, University of British Columbia

    Isabelle Perrault, sociologist

    Stephen J. Randall, University of Calgary

    Jacques Roillard, University of Montreal

    Jean Roy, University of Quebec at Trois-Rivieres

    Donald B. Smith, University of Calgary

    Arthur Silver, University of Toronto

    JDM Stewart, teacher and author

    Mark Thirault, Dawson College

    Ryan Toohy, St. Jerome University

    Jonathan Vance, University of Western Ontario

    Jean-Francois Vieux, historian

    Robert J. Young, University of Winnipeg

    Natalie Sinclair

    Natalie Sinclair is a contributor at Vaughantoday.ca, covering a wide range of topics including local news, politics, business, technology, sports, entertainment, and lifestyle. She focuses on delivering clear, accurate reporting and useful information that helps readers stay informed about current events and issues that matter to their communities. Her work highlights timely developments, relevant stories, and practical insights in a professional and reader-friendly manner.

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

    Related Posts

    As David Barrick Takes the Helm in Whitehorse, a Close Examination of His Record Tells a Reassuring Story

    October 20, 2026

    Intercultural Education and International Programs with Uri Poliavich

    October 7, 2026

    Hamilton Expands Cycling Network with New Federal Investment

    March 28, 2026
    Top Posts

    Windows 11, Microsoft is improving and improving the start menu

    March 2, 2022840 Views

    Zodiac – Detailed Review of an Online Casino

    October 7, 2021476 Views

    Gambling as a Way to Earn Money

    March 31, 2022439 Views

    How to Pertain Real Estate Appraisal

    April 23, 2022438 Views
    Don't Miss
    Economy

    Canada’s Largest LEGO Fan Exhibition Returns to Mississauga With Expanded Venue and More Than 300 Builders

    November 12, 202610 Views

    MISSISSAUGA, Ontario,Bricks in the Six, billed as Canada’s largest annual LEGO fan convention and public…

    New Report Highlights Video Games’ Growing Importance to Canadians

    November 12, 2026

    Amazon Kindle Colorsoft Signature Edition 2026 Draws Strong Interest as New Models Hit Shelves

    November 12, 2026

    Canada Proposes $50 Billion Earthquake Insurance Facility to Prepare for Major Disaster

    November 12, 2026
    About Us

    We cover culture, entertainment, travel, food, wellness, and real-life stories from across Vaughan and beyond.

    We’re currently accepting new media partnerships, brand collaborations, and editorial contributions.

    Email: [email protected]

    Contact: +1-416-555-0134

    Our Picks

    Canada’s Largest LEGO Fan Exhibition Returns to Mississauga With Expanded Venue and More Than 300 Builders

    November 12, 2026

    New Report Highlights Video Games’ Growing Importance to Canadians

    November 12, 2026

    Amazon Kindle Colorsoft Signature Edition 2026 Draws Strong Interest as New Models Hit Shelves

    November 12, 2026
    Most Popular

    Biden announces a bill to grant citizenship to illegal immigrants

    January 17, 20210 Views

    A show noticed when Joe Biden was nominated, before a gala evening

    January 22, 20210 Views

    Jeremiah is still in darkness, Byron assesses daily

    January 23, 20210 Views
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • DMCA
    • Editorial Policy
    • Privacy Policy
    © 2026 VaughanToday.ca — Canadian Lifestyle News & Features. All Rights Reserved.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.